Transgender Athletes in Women’s Sports: The Search for a Fair and Workable Policy Few issues in sports produce more heat—or less productive conversation—than the participation of transgender women in female competition. That’s partly because the debate touches several sensitive questions at once. What makes competition fair? When does a physical advantage become too significant? How should sports balance gender identity with sex-linked athletic differences? And when an event involves tackling, striking, or collision, how much uncertainty about safety is acceptable? The language matters, too. Transgender women are people whose gender identity is female and whose sex was recorded as male at birth. Describing the issue only as “biological males competing against women” highlights concern about sex-linked performance differences, but it can also dismiss the identity and dignity of transgender athletes. A serious discussion has to hold two ideas at once: transgender athletes deserve r...