Tech can't replace human coaches in obesity treatment

-

 

Tech can't replace human coaches in obesity treatment.

Technology alone resulted in worse weight loss compared to tech and a telehealth coach.

   

A new Northwestern Medicine study shows that technology alone cannot replace the human touch in producing meaningful weight loss in obesity treatment.

"Giving people technology alone for the initial phase of obesity treatment produces unacceptably worse weight loss than giving them treatment that combines technology with a human coach," said corresponding study author Bonnie Spring, director of the Center for Behavior and Health and professor of preventive medicine at Northwestern University Feinberg School of Medicine.

The need for low-cost but effective obesity treatments delivered by technology has become urgent as the ongoing obesity epidemic exacerbates burgeoning healthcare costs.

But current technology needs to be more advanced to replace human coaches, Spring said.

In the new SMART study, people who initially only received technology without coach support were less likely to have a meaningful weight loss, considered to be at least 5% of body weight, compared to those who had a human coach at the start.

Investigators intensified treatment quickly (by adding resources after just two weeks) if a person showed less than optimal weight loss. Still, the study showed that the weight loss disadvantage for those who began their weight loss effort without coach support persisted for six months.

The study will be published May 14 in JAMA.

Eventually, more advanced technology may be able to supplant human coaches, Spring said.

"At this stage, the average person still needs a human coach to achieve clinically meaningful weight loss goals because the tech isn't sufficiently developed yet," Spring said. "We may not be so far away from having an AI chatbot that can sub for a human, but we are not quite there yet. It's within reach. The tech is developing really fast."


Previous research showed that mobile health tools for tracking diet, exercise, and weight increase engagement in behavioral obesity treatment. Before this new study, however, it needed to be clarified
whether they produced clinically acceptable weight loss without support from a human coach.

Spring said scientists are now trying to understand what makes human coaches successful and how AI can better imitate humans in terms of content, emotional tone, and context awareness.

Surprising results

"We predicted that starting treatment with technology alone would save money and reduce burden without undermining clinically beneficial weight loss, because treatment augmentation occurred so quickly once poor weight loss was detected," Spring said. "That hypothesis was disproven, however."

Drug and surgical interventions are also available for obesity but have some drawbacks. "They're very expensive, convey medical risks and side effects and aren't equitably accessible," Spring said. Most people who begin taking a GLP-1 agonist stop taking the drug within a year against medical advice, she noted.

Spring said many people can achieve clinically meaningful weight loss without anti-obesity medications, bariatric surgery, or even behavioral treatment. In the SMART study, 25% of people who began treatment with technology alone achieved 5% weight loss after six months without any treatment augmentation. (In fact, the team had to take back the study technologies after three months to recycle them for new participants.)

An unsolved problem in obesity treatment is matching treatment type and intensity to individuals' needs and preferences. "If we could just tell ahead of time who needs which treatment at what intensity, we might start to manage the obesity epidemic," Spring said.

How the study worked

The SMART Weight Loss Management study was a randomized controlled trial that compared two stepped-care treatment approaches for adult obesity. Stepped care offers a way to spread treatment resources across more of the population in need. The treatment that uses the least resources but will benefit some people is delivered first; then, treatment is intensified only for those who show insufficient response. Half of the participants in the SMART study began their weight loss treatment with technology alone. The other half started with gold-standard treatment involving technology and a human coach.

The technology used in the SMART trial was a Wireless Feedback System (an integrated app, Wi-Fi scale, and Fitbit) that participants used to track and receive feedback about their diet, activity, and weight.

Four hundred obese adults between ages 18 and 60 were randomly assigned to begin three months of stepped-care behavioral obesity treatment, beginning with either the Wireless Feedback System (WFS) alone or the WFS plus telehealth coaching. Weight loss was measured after two, four, and eight weeks of treatment, and treatment was intensified at the first sign of suboptimal weight loss (less than .5 pounds per week).

Treatment for both groups began with the same WFS tracking technology. Still, standard-of-care treatment also transmitted the participant's digital data to a coach, who used it to provide behavioral coaching by telehealth. Those showing suboptimal weight loss in either group were re-randomized once to either of two levels of treatment intensification: modest (adding an inexpensive technology component -- supportive messaging) or vigorous (adding both messaging plus a more costly traditional weight loss treatment component -- coaching for those who hadn't received it, meal replacement for those who'd already received coaching).

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

PEOPLE WITH OBESITY BURN LESS CALORIES DURING THE DAY

-
Image
  PEOPLE WITH OBESITY BURN LESS CALORIES DURING THE DAY Building on prior studies with healthy-weight participants, the new research includes different body sizes.         New research indicates that weight influences how and when bodies burn energy. An Oregon Health & Science University study published in the journal  Obesity  found people who have a healthy weight use more energy during the day, when most people are active and eat, while those who are obese spend more energy during the night when most people sleep. The study also found that during the day, those with obesity have higher levels of the hormone insulin -- a sign that the body is working harder to use glucose, an energy-packed sugar. "It was surprising to learn how dramatically the timing of when our bodies burn energy differed in those with obesity," said the study's first author, Andrew McHill, Ph.D., an assistant professor at the OHSU School of Nursing and the Oregon Institute of ...
Read more

WHAT CAUSES ITCHING, AND WHAT STOPS IT?

-
Image
  WHAT CAUSES ITCHING, AND WHAT STOPS IT?         It can be a relief to scratch the occasional itch, but when itch gets out of control, it can become a severe health problem. How does the body know when to stop? Scientists at UC San Francisco are getting close to an answer. In a breakthrough that could transform how doctors treat conditions from eczema to allergies, they have discovered a feedback loop centered on a single immune protein called IL-31 that causes the urge to itch and dials back nearby inflammation. The findings, published on October 13th in  Science Immunology , lay the groundwork for a new generation of drugs that interact more intelligently with the body's innate self-regulating ability. Previous approaches suggested that IL-31 signals itch and promotes skin inflammation. However, the UCSF team discovered that nerve cells, or neurons, that respond to IL-31, triggering a scratch, also prevent immune cells from overreacting and causing more ...
Read more

A VEGAN DIET IMPROVES CARDIOVASCULAR HEALTH, ACCORDING TO A NEW STUDY

-
Image
  A VEGAN DIET IMPROVES CARDIOVASCULAR HEALTH, ACCORDING TO A NEW STUDY         In a study with 22 pairs of identical twins, Stanford Medicine researchers and their colleagues have found that a vegan diet improves cardiovascular health in as little as eight weeks. Although it's well-known that eating less meat improves cardiovascular health, diet studies often need to be enhanced by genetic differences, upbringing, and lifestyle choices. By studying identical twins, however, the researchers were able to control for genetics and limit the other factors, as the twins grew up in the same households and reported similar lifestyles. "Not only did this study provide a groundbreaking way to assert that a vegan diet is healthier than the conventional omnivore diet, but the twins were also a riot to work with," said Christopher Gardner, Ph.D., the Rehnborg Farquhar Professor and a professor of medicine. "They dressed the same, they talked the same, and they had a banter ...
Read more