TREADMILL WORKOUTS: STRENGTHS AND SHORTCOMINGS
TREADMILL WORKOUTS: STRENGTHS AND SHORTCOMINGS
Treadmill workouts are a go-to option for many people thanks to their convenience and ability to deliver consistent cardio exercise. Like any workout, though, they have their strengths and shortcomings.
Effectiveness and Key Benefits
There’s strong evidence that treadmill routines can improve cardiovascular health, help with weight loss, and build endurance.
For example, structured treadmill workouts have been linked to better postural balance and walking ability in older adults (Journal of Aging and Physical Activity, Wiley). Treadmill-based programs have also shown real benefits for people recovering from strokes, including improved aerobic capacity and walking function (AHA Journals). And when it comes to cardiorespiratory fitness—one of the best predictors of long-term health—treadmill running remains a reliable way to make gains (JAMA Network).
A specific treadmill protocol known as the 12-3-30 workout (walking at a 12% incline, three mph, for 30 minutes) has been shown to deliver similar metabolic benefits to self-paced treadmill running. This makes it an appealing, lower-impact option for individuals seeking effective exercise without the strain of running (NIH).
Pros of Treadmill Workouts
One significant advantage is the controlled environment. Treadmills provide a cushioned, predictable surface, which is easier on the joints than pavement, especially helpful for those with joint problems or who are rehabbing injuries (IDEA Fit). They’re also a safe bet in bad weather or when you want to avoid outdoor hazards, and you can easily adjust the speed, incline, and duration to suit your needs.
Another plus is customization: treadmills make switching between intervals and steady-state cardio easy, and you can track things like heart rate and calories in real time (Signos).
Cons of Treadmill Workouts
On the downside, treadmill running can feel monotonous compared to being outside, which may sap motivation for some people (IDEA Fit). Biomechanically, treadmill running changes your gait a bit and doesn’t fully replicate the muscle use or variability of outdoor running. Studies show stride and energy usage differences between treadmill and outdoor workouts (PeerJ).
Treadmills also lack wind resistance or natural inclines, so you’ll miss out on some of the stabilizing muscle work that comes with running outdoors (Springer). Buying a home treadmill can be pricey and require dedicated space, while not everyone has easy access to a gym.
Summary
Treadmill workouts are an effective, safe, and versatile way to boost cardiovascular fitness, burn calories, and support rehab goals. They’re especially valuable for people who need a low-impact, controlled setting. Still, they can get dull, may not build stabilizer muscles as much as outdoor running, and come with equipment costs. For the most well-rounded fitness, many experts recommend mixing treadmill sessions with outdoor workouts to get the best of both worlds (IDEA Fit; PeerJ; Springer).
Comments
Post a Comment